Jimi Hendrix with famous covers. Watch videos, vote for favorites, and explore what makes each interpretation unique."> Jimi Hendrix, All Along the Watchtower, cover vs original, who did it better, best cover songs"> Jimi Hendrix with famous covers. Watch videos, vote for favorites, and explore what makes each interpretation unique.">
ORIGINAL VS COVER

Who Did It Better?

All Along the Watchtower

Bob Dylan (1967) vs Jimi Hendrix (1968)

👑 ORIGINAL

Bob Dylan

John Wesley Harding (1967)

The Original Vision

  • ♪ Sparse acoustic arrangement
  • ♪ Harmonica-driven sound
  • ♪ Recorded in Nashville, October 1967
  • ♪ Biblical imagery & apocalyptic lyrics
  • ♪ 2 minutes 31 seconds

"There are many here among us who feel that life is but a joke..."

👑 COVER

Jimi Hendrix

Electric Ladyland (1968)

The Electric Reinvention

  • ♪ Explosive electric guitar intro
  • ♪ Multiple guitar overdubs
  • ♪ Recorded in London, January 1968
  • ♪ Reached #20 on Billboard Hot 100
  • ♪ 4 minutes 1 second

Dylan himself later said: "Jimi's version... made me feel that it wasn't the same song anymore."

Live Poll Results

Bob Dylan (Original) 0%

0 votes

Jimi Hendrix (Cover) 0%

0 votes

Total votes: 0

The Story Behind the Battle

Dylan's Original (1967)

Bob Dylan wrote "All Along the Watchtower" during his retreat in Woodstock following his 1966 motorcycle accident. The song appeared on John Wesley Harding, a stark departure from the electric sound of his previous albums.

The stripped-down, acoustic arrangement reflects the album's biblical themes and Dylan's return to simplicity. The cryptic lyrics describe a conversation between a joker and a thief.

Hendrix's Cover (1968)

Jimi Hendrix heard Dylan's version and immediately knew he had to record it. His interpretation, released on Electric Ladyland, transformed the song into a psychedelic rock epic.

Hendrix's version became his highest-charting single in the US. Dylan was so impressed that he adopted elements of Hendrix's arrangement for his own live performances of the song.

Dylan's Verdict:

"I liked Jimi Hendrix's record of this and ever since he died I've been doing it that way... Strange how when I sing it, I always feel it's a tribute to him in some kind of way."

More "Who Did It Better?" Coming Soon

Hurt: Johnny Cash vs Nine Inch Nails Knockin' on Heaven's Door: Dylan vs Guns N' Roses Make You Feel My Love: Dylan vs Adele

Comments

Loading comments...